New Article: Authority in Spiritual Philosophies and Religions

“Finding the Self or Losing the Self: Authority and Allegiance in Stoicism, Early Christianity, and Ruism (Confucianism),” Buddhist-Christian Studies. 2026 (46): 43-56.

Abstract:

Spiritual authority and allegiance take strikingly different forms in Stoicism and Ruism (Confucianism) in comparison to early Christianity. Drawing on Pierre Hadot’s account of philosophy as a way of life and Michel Foucault’s analysis of the “care of the self,” a pre-Christian vision of philosophy emerges as transformative spiritual practice rather than mere analytic discourse. Within this horizon, Stoicism locates authority in a disciplined community of teachers and texts, yet ultimately in the autonomous exercise of reason capable of examining doctrine and experience alike. Early Christianity reconfigures authority through obedience to divine revelation mediated by ecclesial structures. Ruism articulates a distinctive model: while affirming hierarchies of heaven, earth, sovereign, parent, and teacher, it subjects all authority to the cosmic Dao as discerned through the conscientious heartmind of each self-cultivating person. Despite significant differences—especially regarding the relation of reason and emotion—Stoicism and Ruism converge in placing final authority within a genuine self transformed through sustained practice. On this basis, a transreligious theology of religious diversity becomes possible, integrating experiential exclusivity, nonconfessional particularity, and relational openness beyond standard typologies of exclusivism, particularism, inclusivism, and pluralism.

Afterthought:

This article marks the first time I have brought Michel Foucault’s later thought into conversation with Pierre Hadot and Ruism. It is also the first time I have explicitly affirmed the similarity between Ruism and Stoicism in terms of their spiritual structure (rather than content).

When I read Foucault’s later work on the so-called hermeneutics of the subject, I was excited. I read it very quickly, as if reading a detective novel, with each page enticing me to turn to the next. It was one of the highlights of my reading last year.

I hope this article has done some justice to his wonderful thought during that period of his intellectual development.

New Updates on Debating Transcendence

1. A Review at Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews

Dr. Leah Kalmanson (University of North Texas) has reviewed Debating Transcendence: Creatio ex nihilo and Sheng Sheng in Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews (April 3, 2026). The review offers an excellent overview of the book’s central arguments and highlights its major contributions. Readers may find it a helpful introduction before reading the book itself.

One particularly insightful observation concerns methodology. Dr. Kalmanson writes: “At this point, I would have been interested to hear some of Song’s methodological commitments articulated in the language of Ruist scholarly practices, although this dimension is implicit in Song’s overall approach to Ruism as a way of life in other chapters.” I appreciate this thoughtful question. In response, I would emphasize that the book operates with two complementary levels of comparative methodology.

The first is developed in the opening two chapters, which clarify what theology means within the Ru tradition and articulate the general Ruist attitude toward learning from other traditions. The second is presented in Chapter Four, where I propose a concrete method for constructing comparative categories that make cross-cultural comparison both meaningful and philosophically rigorous. Regarding the first level, I draw extensively on classical Ruist sources to develop what I call a “rooted and open inclusivism.” For the second, I build primarily upon Dr. Robert C. Neville’s pragmatist methodology—revised through Jonathan Z. Smith’ hermeneutical approach—and argue that Neville’s method provides an appropriate framework for this rooted, open inclusivism.

Dr. Kalmanson’s observation therefore raises an important question, and I hope the clarification above further explains the point she perceptively noted in the second half of her comment.

2. Harvard-Yenching Institute Announcement

The Harvard-Yenching Institute has also announced the publication of the book on its website. I was a Harvard-Yenching Visiting Fellow from 2011 to 2013. During those two years, I devoted myself to careful study of Liu Shu-hsien and Friedrich Schleiermacher. Looking back, that period planted some of the earliest intellectual seeds that eventually grew into Debating Transcendence. It is especially meaningful to see the Institute publicizing the book as it approaches its centennial in 2028. I extend my best wishes for the continued flourishing of Asian studies in the United States and across the globe under the Institute’s aegis.

3. Washington College Magazine Feature

The Spring 2026 issue of Washington College Magazine includes an interview conducted by the College’s Director of Communications, Mark Jolly-Van Bodegraven, featuring both my new book and my colleague Dr. Peter Weigel’s Reading Aquinas’s Five Ways: The Arguments for God in Summa Theologiae (Cambridge University Press, 2025).

The interview situates Debating Transcendence within the liberal arts tradition inaugurated by Aristotle, suggesting that asking and attempting to answer the deepest human questions liberates the mind, and that such intellectual freedom forms one of the foundations of a robust democracy.

The interview also discusses my co-authored chapter, “When the Fire Came: A Retelling of the Confucian Sacred Story,“ written with Dr. Anna Sun (Duke University) and Dr. Pauline Lee (Saint Louis University). I am also delighted to share that this chapter has been adopted by colleagues at Washington College as a course reading for an environmental literature class co-taught by professors of English and Art History. They have told me that it has become one of the most relevant and engaging readings for the course.

4. American Academy of Religion Book Panel

The 2026 Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Religion in Denver will feature a book panel on Debating Transcendence, co-sponsored by the Confucian Traditions Unit and the Comparative Theology Unit. The official announcement can be found here.

I very much look forward to the thoughtful discussions and intellectual exchanges that this panel will foster among colleagues and friends.

5. American Philosophical Association Book Panel

The 2027 Eastern Division Meeting of the American Philosophical Association in Boston will also host a book panel on Debating Transcendence, sponsored by the International Society for Chinese Philosophy. This gathering will provide an opportunity to engage once again with my doctoral advisor, Dr. Robert C. Neville, my dissertation reader, Dr. Stephen Angle, and several close academic friends. I look forward to a stimulating and enjoyable exchange of ideas.


Overall, I am deeply grateful for the warm reception the book has received so far. Seeing it generate thoughtful reviews, public discussions, classroom use, and scholarly panels is both encouraging and humbling. I hope these conversations will continue to advance comparative theology, Confucian studies, and cross-cultural philosophy in the years ahead.

“The Rang Stream Study Hall” by Zhou Dunyi

Introduction

In the lineage of Ru exemplars within the Daoxue movement, Zhou Dunyi (周敦颐, 1017-1073) was frequently was frequently regarded as the pioneering figure. Born into a family with a long tradition of passing the highest civil examinations and serving in government, Zhou was steeped in Ruist teachings from a young age. At the age of 24, he began his official career upon his uncle’s recommendation, holding various local governmental positions until his passing at 57.

Regarding Zhou Dunyi’s personality and governance style, his contemporary Huang Tingjian (1145-1105), a renowned calligrapher, poet, and scholar-official, once praised him as follows:

“Mr. Zhou Dunyi possessed a serene and open heart, akin to the sunlit breeze and luminous moon after a rainfall. He was humble in seeking recognition yet determined in pursuing his aspirations. Personal fortune held little value to him, as his dedication lay in serving others. He practiced restraint in his own pleasures but extended generosity to the widowed and lonely. While contemporary acclaim mattered little to him, he cherished enduring friendships that transcend time.” (Huang, et al., 1846, vol 12, p.26.)

Huang’s metaphorical description, “the sunlit breeze and luminous moon after a rainfall (光風霽月),” has been widely cited by later Ru scholars. Hence, it serves as the inspiration for the title of this collection of Neo-Confucian poetry.

A few notable points about Zhou’s thought, as expressed in the following translated poetry:

Firstly, Zhou’s attitude towards Buddhism and Daoism, two major contemporary spiritual traditions that had significant influence among Ru literati in his time, remained more open and appreciative than that of most translated Ru masters in this collection. He frequently visited Buddhist temples and Daoist shrines, interacting with practitioners of both traditions, and expressing a longing to live a hermetic life in mountains and forests. Several poems thematizing hermit life attest to Zhou’s enduring interest in this aspect.

Secondly, however, the Ru tradition, starting from Confucius, also emphasizes a hermetic life under necessary circumstances. As particularly indicated by “Passing the Ancient Temple,” Zhou Dunyi’s genuine intention in thematizing hermit life in his poetry was to incorporate Buddhist and Daoist influences into an overall Ruist framework. He displayed a unique Ruist lifestyle that simultaneously addressed worldly concerns and lofty spiritual aspirations. As we’ll explore further in the following chapters, Zhou’s approach to the multi-spiritual environment of his time is shared by many Ru poets and exemplars.

Thirdly, in “The Rang Stream Study Hall,” Zhou named a stream in Mount Lu as Lian (integrity), following a Ru predecessor who admired the name of another stream in the same region as Rang (deference). In “A Letter from My Governmental Post to Old Acquaintances in My Hometown,” Zhou sought to preempt corruption by emphasizing his modest lifestyle to his old acquaintances. And in “On Loving the Lotus,” Zhou expressed his love for the lotus as “the epitome of noble virtues,” contrasting it with the hermit’s love for the chrysanthemum. These poems reflect Zhou Dunyi’s commitment to the Ruist lifestyle focused on cultivating noble virtues, explaining why the Ru lineage of the Daoxue movement in the Song Dynasty regarded him as an initiator.

瀼溪書堂

元子溪曰瀼,詩傳到於今。

此俗良易化,不欺顧相钦。

廬山我久愛,買田山之陰。

田間有流水,清泚出山心。

山心無塵土,白石磷磷沈。

潺湲來數里,到此始澄深。

有龍不可測,岸木寒森森。

書堂構其上,隱几看雲岑。

倚梧或欹枕,風月盈中襟。

或吟或冥默,或酒或鳴琴。

數十黃卷軸,聖賢談無音。

窗前叩疇囿,囿外桑麻林。

芋蔬可卒歲,絹布足衣衾。

飽煖大富貴,康寧無價金。

吾樂蓋易足,名濂朝暮箴。

元子与周子,相邀风月寻。

The Rang Stream Study Hall

Master Yuan’s creek, called Rang, a humble stream,

Carries forth his poetic theme (i).

Here, customs shift with a gentle sway,

Honest folk nod with respect, day by day.

Mount Lu, steeped in longing and lore,

I acquired fields on its northern floor.

Another stream meanders through, crisp and pure,

Born from the mountain’s heart, steady and sure.

In the mountain’s heart, where no dust dwells,

White rocks, sturdy and jagged, clear the veil.

Winding its way, gaining depth and gleam,

The stream holds a hidden dragon, in waters unseen.

Around it, trees stand stark and pristine.

I built a study hall beside the stream, concealed behind a low table,

Gazing up at clouds, in peaks above.

Leaning against a parasol tree or on a tilted pillow, I find my rest,

Wind and moon come to fill the folds of my robe.

Sometimes chanting, or in silence deep,

Sometimes with wine, or a zither’s sweep.

Dozens of yellow scrolls lie beside,

Where sages and worthies converse without a sound.

By the window, tapping on the garden grounds;

Beyond, a grove of mulberry and hemp abounds.

Taro and vegetables suffice for the year,

Silk and cloth enough for clothes and quilts.

Warmth and fullness, the truest of riches,

Contentment worth more than gold’s entices.

My joy is easily fulfilled, naming the stream Lian, “Integrity,” (ii)

As my daily guide.

Master Yuan and I, inviting each other here,

Seek the company of the wind and moon.

Notes:

(i) Yuan Jie (719-772) was a Ru scholar and government official during the Tang Dynasty (618-907). Upon relocating his family to the region of Mount Lu (廬山), he discovered a local stream named Rang (瀼), which phonetically resembled the virtue of Rang (讓), meaning deference or humility. He composed poems to honor this stream and the life it nurtured.

(ii) Lian (濂), phonetically resembling the virtue of Lian (廉), signifying honesty or integrity. Zhou Dunyi’s choice to name and write poetry about this new stream demonstrated his admiration for his predecessor, Yuan Jie.

Commentary:

According to the “Biography of Zhou Dunyi (周敦頤年譜)” of Zhou (1990, p.99),  Zhou Dunyi was appointed as a Circuit Judge (通判) in Qian Zhou of the Mount Lu region in 1061, at the age of 45. This poem was composed in the same year, depicting Zhou’s establishment of a residence near the newly named Lian stream. Zhou Dunyi, known by his pen name Lian Xi (濂溪), was often referred to as Master Stream of Integrity by Ru literati. This poem sheds light on the origin of his pen name.

Bin Song Interviewed by Journal of Contemplative Studies

Inspired by the ancient Confucian tradition, this conversation explores a timely question: How can we meditate as scholars, administrators, or modern professionals?

I also explain the misnomer of “Confucianism,” clarifying the Ruist (Confucian) tradition of contemplative practices and self-cultivation, and distinguishing it from other major ancient Asian traditions, such as Chinese Mahayana Buddhism.

Excerpt:

Contemplation in the Ru tradition is best understood as a state of heightened attention grounded in reverence. It means focusing your energy and aligning your consciousness with a guiding principle in order to gain insight into reality and engage with it.

What does heightened attention involve? It requires integrating all dimensions of the self, including understandings, feelings, emotions, actions, and more. This is traditionally described as sincerity or authenticity (cheng). You study ethical and metaphysical teachings, practice them, and cultivate a unified way of living. This coherence is what Ru thinkers mean by heightened attention.

And what about insights? As we see in Buddhism’s emphasis on mindfulness, many traditions seek direct, unclouded awareness of reality. Ruists (or Confucians) also aim for this: accessing reality free from prejudice and partiality. However, each tradition defines reality in its own way.

The full interview can be checked here.

Patience in Interfaith Teaching 

The following essay reflects my Interfaith teaching experience at Washington College, published by the Interfaith America Magazine (https://www.interfaithamerica.org/article/patience-in-interfaith-teaching/)

Excerpt:

“…I define patience as a radical acceptance of obstacles or burdens we face on the path to any meaningful goal. Imperfection is an inevitable part of human experience. Recognizing this, especially when navigating challenges related to faith, has become invaluable in my teaching. Patience allows me — and my students — to embrace our differences and cultivate deeper, more meaningful cross-cultural and interfaith understanding. I’ve had three key teaching experiences that illustrate the profound impact of patience in the classroom …”